Open Meeting Law
Legal requirements that HOA board meetings be open to association members, with limited exceptions for confidential matters discussed in executive session. Open meeting laws are the cornerstone of transparency in HOA governance, ensuring that homeowners can observe how decisions affecting their property and community are made. While the specifics vary by state, open meeting laws typically require: advance notice of all board meetings (including the date, time, location, and agenda), posting the agenda in a location accessible to members, allowing members to attend and observe all open-session proceedings, providing members an opportunity to speak on agenda items before the board votes, and recording decisions in publicly available minutes. In California, the Davis-Stirling Act (Civil Code Sections 4900-4955) contains some of the most comprehensive open meeting requirements for HOAs in the country. Key provisions include: the agenda must be posted at least four days before a board meeting (Civil Code Section 4920), members must be allowed to speak at any meeting on any item on the agenda (Civil Code Section 4925), the board may not take action on items not listed on the agenda except for emergencies, and the board cannot conduct business by email, serial phone calls, or any form of communication outside a properly noticed meeting (Civil Code Section 4910). Violations of open meeting requirements can render board actions voidable and may subject the association to legal challenges. Members who believe the board has violated open meeting requirements may pursue remedies including internal dispute resolution and court action. Board members should treat open meeting compliance as non-negotiable — it builds trust, reduces conflict, and protects the board from legal liability.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can HOA board members discuss association business by email?
In California, no. Civil Code Section 4910 prohibits the board from taking action on any item of association business outside of a properly noticed board meeting. This includes email chains, group texts, serial phone calls, and any other form of communication where a majority of directors discuss and reach consensus outside of a meeting. Individual emails between a board member and management requesting information are generally acceptable, but deliberation among a majority of the board must occur at a noticed meeting.